.png)
Cart Upsell vs. Post-Purchase Upsell vs. One-Click Upsell — Which Converts Best?
TL;DR
Cart upsells, post-purchase upsells, and one-click post-purchase upsells are all valuable tools — but they work differently. Cart upsells raise the average order value (AOV) before checkout. Post-purchase upsells add incremental revenue without risking the sale. One-click upsells tend to get the highest acceptance rates because they require no re-entry of payment details. The best results come when brands use a hybrid approach: cart upsells for order value + one-click post-purchase upsells for incremental revenue.
What Each Upsell Type Means
Cart Upsell (Pre-Checkout)
Offers shown on the cart page or cart drawer before checkout — ideal for bundles, add-ons, or upgrades.
Post-Purchase Upsell
Offers presented immediately after checkout (e.g. on thank-you page) — after payment is confirmed.
One-Click Upsell
A type of post-purchase upsell where customers add an extra item via a single click — no re-entering payment info.
Strengths and Limitations
Performance Insights & Data
- According to data from a leading Shopify post-purchase upsell app, one-click upsells have an average acceptance rate of approx. 4.7%.
- Merchants using post-purchase upsells reported ~5.6% AOV uplift thanks to incremental post-order sales.
- Upselling techniques in subscription-based or recurring-purchase setups tend to outperform acquisition-based growth, because increasing AOV or recurring revenue per customer is cheaper than acquiring new customers.
Key takeaway: one-click post-purchase upsells reliably deliver incremental revenue, while cart upsells maximize the value of the primary transaction. The optimal approach blends both.
Which Upsell Type Fits Which Goal
Best Practices for Shopify Upsells
- Offer relevant, complementary products (e.g. accessories, bundles) — relevance drives conversion.
- Keep upsell offers minimal and focused — 1 or 2 good suggestions beat many random ones.
- Prioritize smooth, mobile-optimized UX.
- Use one-click funnels for post-purchase upsells — reduce friction and increase acceptance.
- Test and iterate: A/B test upsell placement, messaging, and offer types to determine what converts best for your store.
Why Subscriptions + Upsells Amplify Revenue
For stores selling replenishable or recurring products (beauty, supplements, pet care, etc.), combining upsells with subscriptions can turn a one-time AOV increase into recurring revenue and higher lifetime value.
A tool like Loop Subscriptions supports one-click upsells, recurring bundles, and subscription flows — helping convert upsell revenue into predictable long-term income.
This means the extra AOV from upsells doesn’t just boost immediate revenue — it becomes recurring, compounding over time.
How to Combine Upsells for Maximum Impact
- Use cart upsells to raise order size during checkout.
- Immediately after purchase, present a one-click post-purchase upsell or subscription upgrade.
- If the offer converts, retain the customer over time using subscription tools such as Loop Subscriptions.
This captures value at multiple points — maximizing each customer’s lifetime revenue potential.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Q. Which upsell type converts best on average?
One-click post-purchase upsells — because post-purchase friction is minimal, they typically deliver the highest acceptance rates.
Q. Is cart upsell still worth doing if you use post-purchase upsells?
Yes — cart upsells maximize the value of the current order, while post-purchase upsells generate incremental revenue after the sale. Together, they maximize total revenue per customer.
Q. What kinds of products work best for upsells?
Complementary items, add-ons, or upgrades: e.g. accessories, bundle items, consumables, or subscription-eligible products.
Q. Do upsells risk hurting checkout conversion?
Only if they’re irrelevant or too aggressive. Keep offers simple, relevant, and user-friendly.
Q. How do I measure upsell performance?
Track upsell acceptance rate, incremental revenue, AOV lift, and overall checkout conversion rate.
Table of contents
.png)
