Comparing Loop with?
Running a 7-9 figure subscription business isn't the same as running a startup. The problems are different. The stakes are higher.
At this scale, you're not just trying to get subscribers—you're trying to keep them. You're not just processing orders—you're managing thousands of SKUs, delivery schedules, and payment failures across a complex operation. And you're not just watching costs—you're watching margins get squeezed by per-order fees that seemed negligible at $100K but feel crushing at $10M.
Most subscription apps were built for brands just getting started. They work fine as a basic Shopify subscribe and save app for small catalogs—but they weren't designed for the complexity of high-volume subscription management. Loop was built for brands that have already made it—and need infrastructure that matches their ambition.
Here's what makes Loop the best Shopify subscription app for 7-9 figure brands.
At scale, the math changes. Acquiring a new subscriber costs 5-7x more than keeping an existing one. A 5% improvement in retention can increase profits by 25-95%. Yet most subscription apps treat retention as an afterthought—a basic cancellation flow and some generic win-back emails. If you're serious about how to reduce subscription churn on Shopify, your platform needs to do far more than surface-level cancellation popups.
They treat every churning customer the same. A subscriber who's been with you for 7 orders gets the same "Are you sure?" popup as someone who signed up last month. That's not retention strategy—that's laziness.
Generic cancellation offers that ignore customer history leave significant revenue on the table. When every subscriber sees the same discount regardless of their loyalty or lifetime value, you're either over-discounting new customers or under-serving your most valuable ones.
.png)
Personalized cancellation flows that adapt based on customer history, reason for leaving, and subscription value. A high-LTV customer considering cancellation gets a different experience than a first-month churn. Loop's cancellation flows support 20+ segmentation attributes, letting you serve different videos, offers, and alternative actions based on who's trying to leave and why.
Mystery rewards and tiered incentives that automatically reward subscribers at key milestones. Instead of waiting for customers to consider leaving, Loop Flows help you proactively build loyalty. Triggers fire at high-churn inflection points (often order #3 or #4) before customers ever click "cancel."
Livingood Daily used Loop Flows to set up a rewards system offering an additional 5% discount on top of their existing 15% subscription discount—automatically applied on the third order. The result: subscription revenues grew by 40% and churn dropped to 2%.
Exit surveys that actually drive action. Collect structured data on why customers leave, then use those insights to fix the underlying issues—not just patch symptoms. Loop's cancellation analytics dashboard shows you exactly where the leaks are in your funnel.
Managing 500 subscribers is manageable. Managing 50,000 across multiple products, delivery frequencies, and variants? That's where most subscription apps break down—and where you need a subscription management platform built for Shopify stores operating at scale.
Multiple delivery frequencies (weekly, monthly, quarterly). Product variants that need independent subscription logic. Inventory that needs to stay synced across Shopify. Customers who want to skip, swap, pause, and modify without calling support.
At scale, these aren't edge cases—they're daily operations.
Common pain points include manually updating delivery dates for out-of-stock items one subscription at a time, dealing with "ghost products" and phantom SKUs that throw off inventory reporting, and spending hours on CSV exports just to make bulk changes.
Flexible delivery frequencies without workarounds. Handle monthly, bi-monthly, quarterly—or custom cadences—natively. Keep existing subscribers on their current delivery schedules (like an 8-week cadence) while offering only your preferred frequency options to new customers—no complicated workarounds required.
No phantom SKUs. Loop integrates directly with Shopify's inventory system. When a bundle sells, the individual line items appear correctly on the Shopify order page at the required price—no "ghost" products, no manual reconciliation, no inventory nightmares. This means accurate sales breakdowns and clean fulfillment reporting without inventing fake SKUs.
Intelligent sold-out management. When products go out of stock, automatically notify customers and offer alternatives—without breaking the subscription or requiring manual intervention. Loop supports partial billing, automatic order delays, and smart inventory forecasting so you know exactly what's coming before orders hit Shopify.
Bulk actions that actually work. Reschedule orders for out-of-stock items in seconds. Filter subscriptions by SKU and next charge date, then bulk-update delivery dates automatically—no CSV exports required.
A self-service customer portal that actually works. Customers can skip, pause, swap products, update payment methods, and change delivery dates themselves. Loop's drag-and-drop portal builder lets you customize every element to match your brand. Your support team handles exceptions, not routine requests.
Simplified pricing during sales and promotions. Running a site-wide discount shouldn't mean hours of manual work. With most platforms, you risk double-discounting subscribers or spending hours updating prices in both Shopify and your subscription app—then reversing everything when the sale ends.
Loop automates this entirely. Set a higher discount on the initial order (e.g., 40% off during your promotion) and automatically revert to the regular subscription discount (e.g., 20%) on all recurring orders. No manual price changes. No double-discounting errors. And because many subscribers cancel just to re-subscribe at sale prices, Loop's personalized cancellation flows help intercept this behavior—keeping customers engaged instead of gaming your promotions.
Here's what most subscription apps don't advertise: their fee structures are designed to extract more from every order as you grow—not because they're helping you succeed, but because growth triggers higher costs for you and higher margins for them.
The hidden cost problem
Per-order fees of $0.10-0.20 seem trivial at 1,000 orders/month. At 50,000 orders/month, that's $5,000-10,000 in fees—on top of your monthly subscription. Add unclear tier breakdowns and surprise charges, and forecasting costs becomes impossible.
Many platforms also require forecasting sales 12 months in advance—introducing both forecasting risk and currency risk for international merchants. Exceed your projection? Get penalized with higher per-transaction fees. Need advanced retention features? Pay an extra $1,000+ per month for add-ons that should be standard.
No per-order fees. A fixed monthly fee plus a transparent 0.75% transaction percentage. That's it.
Clear pricing tiers that tell you exactly what features and support you get at each level. All core retention features—cancellation flows, mystery rewards, gamification, dunning management—are included. No hidden add-on costs.
Predictable scaling. When you're forecasting next year's P&L, you shouldn't need a spreadsheet just to figure out what your subscription app will cost. Loop's pricing rewards your growth instead of penalizing it—the rate only decreases at higher volumes.
Livingood Daily saved almost 50% on subscription platform costs after migrating to Loop. That's the kind of margin improvement that compounds as you scale.
At 7-9 figures, "growth" isn't about adding a basic upsell widget. It's about infrastructure that systematically increases revenue per subscriber while reducing friction throughout the customer journey. For brands focused on subscription LTV optimization, the difference between a feature and a system is everything.
Inefficient product pages that don't convert one-time buyers to subscribers. Missed upsell opportunities buried in clunky customer portals. Failed payments that churn subscribers who actually wanted to stay.
Static upsell sections that show the same products to every subscriber regardless of their purchase history or loyalty status leave money on the table. And when payment recovery is an afterthought, you're losing revenue that should be yours.
Subscription-first product pages that make subscribing the obvious choice. Loop's customizable widget lets you set subscribe-and-save as the default option, highlight savings clearly, and communicate future benefits (like higher discounts on the third order) to incentivize one-time buyers to subscribe.
NutriPaw grew first-time subscription orders from 4% to 20% by making subscribe-and-save the default option on their product pages—resulting in 130% growth in subscription conversions and a 73.5% increase in subscription revenue over 9 months.
Personalized upsell and cross-sell capabilities built into the subscriber experience. Loop's Upsell Profiles let you create segmentation rules based on LTV, products subscribed to, order count, and more—then display different product recommendations and personalized discounts to each segment. No hard-coding required; pull directly from Shopify collections and A/B test for conversion.
Advanced dunning that recovers revenue. Up to 15 intelligent retry attempts at optimized intervals. Backup payment methods that automatically retry secondary cards if the primary fails. Pre-authenticated Quick Action URLs in failed payment emails let customers update their card with a single click—no password, no OTP, no friction.
Mammaly saw 30% of subscribers update payment methods via Quick Actions, with an 18% reactivation rate through seamless customer experience. Failed payments shouldn't be a leak—they should be a solvable problem.
Proactive retention with Loop Flows. Set up automated actions triggered by specific milestones: product swaps at X orders, higher discounts at Y orders, gift products at Z orders. Create streaks and gamification that reward consistency and give customers "something to lose" if they cancel.
Your subscription app doesn't exist in isolation. It needs to talk to your email platform, your SMS tool, your CRM, your analytics stack. When those integrations are fragmented or unreliable, you end up with data silos, broken automations, and operational headaches.
Most subscription apps bolt on integrations as an afterthought. Data doesn't sync reliably. Events don't fire consistently. You end up building custom workarounds just to get basic functionality.
Payment gateway complexity creates additional headaches—when customers change payment methods, tokens can get trapped in the wrong system, creating growing administrative nightmares.
Native Shopify integration that uses Shopify's APIs directly. Product management, inventory sync, and checkout all work the way they're supposed to. Changes made to products or variants in Shopify sync in real-time—no manual re-uploading, no variant mapping headaches.
Deep Klaviyo integration that syncs subscription events in real-time. Trigger flows based on subscription milestones, churn risk, upcoming renewals—without custom development. Loop Flows can push custom events to Klaviyo automatically, enabling advanced marketing automations specific to each subscriber segment.
No-code setup for CRM and backend tool connections. Your team shouldn't need engineering resources just to connect your subscription data to your marketing stack. Loop integrates with major platforms including Gorgias, Zendesk, Attentive, Postscript, Rise.ai, and more. View the full integrations directory.
Passwordless login that works globally. Loop uses Shopify session cookies and pre-authenticated URLs to provide a single-click login experience from emails directly into the portal. No OTP issues for international customers, no activation barriers for new subscribers.
Loop isn't trying to be everything to everyone. It's purpose-built for brands that have already proven product-market fit and are now focused on scaling DTC subscriptions profitably.
Retention-first design. Every feature is evaluated against one question: does this help brands keep subscribers longer? From personalized cancellation flows to proactive mystery rewards, Loop's entire architecture prioritizes LTV over acquisition gimmicks.
Operational scalability. Built to handle complexity without creating operational burden. Bulk actions that don't require CSV exports. Bundles that don't create ghost SKUs. Portals that customers can actually navigate without calling support.
Transparent economics. Pricing that rewards your growth instead of penalizing it. No per-order fees. No hidden add-on costs. No surprise surcharges for exceeding arbitrary limits. When brands compare Loop against other options in a Shopify subscription app comparison, the cost advantage becomes clear at every tier.
Dedicated partnership. A Customer Success Manager who acts as an extension of your team—not a quarterly checkbox. Dedicated Slack channels with average response times under 30 minutes. 24/7 critical issue support. Strategy sessions that deliver actionable insights, not just "high-level" observations.
Proven at scale. Brands processing $2B+ in subscription revenue trust Loop. OSEA Malibu cut churn from 10% to 5% in six months using a combination of visual rewards journeys, personalized cancellation flows, and tiered upsell strategies. TruHeight grew their subscriber base by 314% in 12 months by combining smart dunning, a customizable customer portal, and data-driven cancellation flows. Good Protein saw 400% subscriber growth in 4 months through gamified rewards and personalized cancellation flows. Lilac St. increased subscription revenue by 72.7% in 11 months with Loop's bundle builder.
If you're running a 7-9 figure subscription business on Shopify, you need infrastructure that matches your scale—not a tool you've outgrown.
Join 1,065+ brands processing $2B+ in subscription revenue with Loop's tools.
Schedule a consultation with our team or start your free trial to see how Loop can transform your subscription management.
